In the 1850 Stark County, Ohio Census, Samuel and Elizabeth and theirchildren reside in Washington Township next door to Samuel's brother, Benjamin. Samuel is a farmer.

In the 1860 Stark County, Ohio Census, Samuel and his family reside in Washington Township. He is a farmer.

In the 1870 Stark County, Ohio Census, Samuel and Eliza reside in Washington Township. The record states that Samuel was born in New Jersey, that he is a farmer, and that his Real Estate value is $35,000.00. They reside two dwellings from his brother Joseph.

In the 1880 Stark County, Ohio Census Samuel and Eliza reside in Washington Township. Samuel is a farmer. According to this record, Samuel's parents were both born in New Jersey. Their niece, Annie Stall, aged 20 and born in Ohio, resides with them.
Stark County, Ohio Death Records state that Samuel died of old age, aged 73 years 10 months, and that he was born in New Jersey.

Samuel is buried next to his wife. His marker states "d 5 Aug 1884 ae 73y 10m 27d".